GTAStunting

GTA Series => Grand Theft Auto - San Andreas => SA Stunting Challenges => Topic started by: marklund on July 28, 2005, 04:12:52 PM

Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 28, 2005, 04:12:52 PM: http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2232 (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2232) - danye_36

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2234 (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2234) - Mr. Magic

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynam...3_-_Impulse.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&file=SVC3_-_Impulse.rar) - Impulse

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynam...rklund_SVC3.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&file=marklund_SVC3.rar) - Marklund

http://files.filefront.com/kr3mlins_SVC_3_...;/fileinfo.html (http://files.filefront.com/kr3mlins_SVC_3_Entry/;3970947;;/fileinfo.html) - Kr3mlin

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.p...s_SVC_3_vid.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.php?file=Yodas_SVC_3_vid.rar) - Yoda_jedimaster

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.p...en__-__SVC3.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.php?file=Freden__-__SVC3.rar) - Freden

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2244 (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2244) - Buzzsaw

First to 10 votes wins!

NO VOTINGS ON YOURSELF!

[span style=\'font-size:21pt;line-height:100%\']DO WATCH ALL VIDS BEFORE VOTING![/span]
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Juan on July 28, 2005, 04:38:40 PM: Buzzsaw gets my vote he had the best unique stunt which was the backwards stoppie on the trolley, I was going to enter, but too late :( i had a fallgrab of the top of the crane, a roof jump by bumping of the crane's wreckingball, and i roofed the trainstation on a mountainbike.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 28, 2005, 04:44:00 PM: Buzzsaw, what vid did you vote? Not your own uh? :P
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: blah on July 28, 2005, 04:50:44 PM: kr3mlin got my vote.

The video flowed really well together...

But yea thats a lot of videos to download and watch so I have a feeling this is going to turn into a popularity contest, because I doubt a lot of people will take the time to download all of those... So they'll just vote for their friends.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Buzzsaw on July 28, 2005, 04:53:13 PM: marklund, i haven't voted for anyone yet. i still haven't watched them all. ;)

i just hope people judge the vids on the stunts only and not the editing. i myself put virtually no effort into editing simply because it seems like a waste of time for challenge/contest vids.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 28, 2005, 04:54:58 PM: Look here, if I get ANY submissions that has cheated votes (voted on themself), I'll remove it. Same if anyones says to another guy for example "Vote my vid man" and he does it without watching ALL the vids. It really sucks when people do this. The competitors is stressing as hell to make the vids look good. And it would be good if you voted AND wrote a post about who you voted on and why.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Test Bear on July 28, 2005, 04:58:02 PM: I voted for Buzzsaw, his vid was good as it had no NRG, and I loved the bike stoppie on the trolley. Second would be kr3mlin, and third would be Freden. Good luck everyone.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Freden on July 28, 2005, 04:59:10 PM: i have watch all vids...
and i decided to vote for Marklund beacuse i like his backwardstoppie with the NRG and his duouble bump to the other roof..
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 28, 2005, 05:03:58 PM: I voted Freden because it was his first vid and he showed us a very nice crane grind with a plane! :)
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Buzzsaw on July 28, 2005, 05:06:27 PM: my vote goes to krem. the car flips off the packer collision and packer strut bump-to-roof r0x0rz0rz0r.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: kr3mlin on July 28, 2005, 05:30:35 PM: Voted Freden. I liked some of his roof bumps esp the one to the higher roof and a plane grind is def something different

EDIT: I think editing does have a place as well as stunts, i mean some stunts dont look as good if they are edited poorly and on the same note good editing can elevate a vid. For example dannye his intro was really well done and it is the one intro that stuck in my head
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Southern Finest on July 28, 2005, 06:29:02 PM: Blahs right, there should only be a certain number of people allowed to enter. Say maybe the first 3 vids?
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Dannye on July 28, 2005, 06:40:10 PM: Quote
...I think editing does have a place as well as stunts, i mean some stunts dont look as good if they are edited poorly and on the same note good editing can elevate a vid. For example dannye his intro was really well done and it is the one intro that stuck in my head
Hey thanks :) . I think that we should be able to judge a little bit on editing, but mostly on the actual stunts, especially when you consider the relatively short time we have for each challenge. Stunts should be the most important, but ofcourse, great editing does make the stunts look/flow better, and if (for example) you couldnt decide which to vote for out of 2 entries (you narrowed it down to the two best, stunt wise), then it would be perfectly logical to then vote for the one that just looks/flows the best, hence had the best editing.

Edit: Just watched all the vids now, great stuff people. If i hadnt already given a null vote (tryin to be fair), then i probably wouldve voted for Freden, Kr3mlin or Marklund (Glad i dont have to choose now, becuase its a hard decision :P ). Freden, that plane 'grind' was certainly different, lol, i liked it, and I must say Buzzsaw, that bicyclestoppie blew me away, awesome dude :grin: .

Edit: (In reply to SF's point) I know it can be annoying if heaps of ppl enter, cause you have to dl them all (especially for ppl with slower internet connections), but i think it'd be unfair to put a limit and say 'only the first X vids will get in'. If you really want to lower the amount of entrants then just cut the time limit a bit - but I think its fine how it is and we should make no changes at all in that regards.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Buzzsaw on July 28, 2005, 06:58:00 PM: having to put time into editing an intro and video effects and all that stuff makes it even more difficult to do these challenges in only a few days. if you start judging the editing too then there will be a decrease in the quality of stunts because people have to use up time to do fancy editing when they could otherwise be working on better stunts. besides, this is supposed to be a stunt challenge, not an editing challenge.

EDIT: if you're gonna limit the number of entrees then you'd have to announce the contestants BEFORE people spend time working on a submission, otherwise if someone doesn't make it in then they just wasted a lot of time and effort for no reason.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 28, 2005, 07:02:00 PM: Yeah, no limits. :)
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: finallight on July 28, 2005, 07:14:33 PM: This is a Stunt Video competition so I've been judging the overall vid, editing, stunts, music, just like a regular vid.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 28, 2005, 07:16:16 PM: Quote
This is a Stunt Video competition so I've been judging the overall vid, editing, stunts, music, just like a regular vid.
That's how I want people to vote on the vids too. :)
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Buzzsaw on July 28, 2005, 07:25:09 PM: i thought the rules said to judge the vids based on the stunts, which is why i didn't put any effort into editing. oh well...
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: BomberBoy on July 28, 2005, 07:41:31 PM: Quote
http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2232 (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2232) - danye_36

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2234 (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2234) - Mr. Magic

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynam...3_-_Impulse.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&file=SVC3_-_Impulse.rar) - Impulse

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynam...rklund_SVC3.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&file=marklund_SVC3.rar) - Marklund

http://files.filefront.com/kr3mlins_SVC_3_...;/fileinfo.html (http://files.filefront.com/kr3mlins_SVC_3_Entry/;3970947;;/fileinfo.html) - Kr3mlin

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.p...s_SVC_3_vid.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.php?file=Yodas_SVC_3_vid.rar) - Yoda_jedimaster

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.p...en__-__SVC3.rar (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/dynamic.php?file=Freden__-__SVC3.rar) - Freden

http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2244 (http://www.thegamersalliance.com/?do=dynamic&id=2244) - Buzzsaw

First to 10 votes wins!

NO VOTINGS ON YOURSELF!

[span style=\'font-size:21pt;line-height:100%\']DO WATCH ALL VIDS BEFORE VOTING![/span]
i'm not going to d/l all those :nono:

can we start putfile'ing it?
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: kr3mlin on July 28, 2005, 07:55:02 PM: And herein lies the problem of SVC, which i think rocks but then again none of those files are small enough for putfile
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Dannye on July 28, 2005, 07:56:24 PM: Quote
This is a Stunt Video competition so I've been judging the overall vid, editing, stunts, music, just like a regular vid.
I reckon thats okay as long as we all make sure we put more emphasis on the stunts when voting. (I dont mean put all the emphasis on the stunts, just more than we do on each of the other sections). Each time I have voted sofar the stunts have been the main thing i looked at, with the editing used to help distinguish between vids which have evenly good stunts, and hence couldnt decide between on stunts alone.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: kr3mlin on July 28, 2005, 07:59:25 PM: i think this discussion might be best placed in the SVC challenges thread and leave this one for discussions on SVC 3 entries, just a thought.

Dannye_36 those packer strut bumps, you can push those to the limit ive been doing them for a while and you can get 70ft jumps (though rarely) but mostly bout 63ft ones. But i love em and good to see them in another SVC entry :P
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Free Mike on July 28, 2005, 08:03:35 PM: This is a lot to download. I'm gonna choose on overall video too. I've watched 3 so far and Freden has my vote right now. Will wait to vote till I've seen them all though. :D

EDIT:

It was close between kr3mlin, Freden, and a couple ithers, but kr3mlin got my vote. Great work you guys!
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: BomberBoy on July 28, 2005, 09:12:23 PM: *null vote...doesn't d/l...waits*
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Dannye on July 28, 2005, 11:10:05 PM: Quote
Dannye_36 those packer strut bumps, you can push those to the limit ive been doing them for a while and you can get 70ft jumps (though rarely) but mostly bout 63ft ones. But i love em and good to see them in another SVC entry :P
Thanks for the advice Kr3mlin, I only just found out about them a few days ago (by accident :D , i was doing a normal packer bump, lost control, went at it at a bad angle, hit the strut and actually did a nice stunt, lol), and i really like them now. Its like being able to do a packer-bump without needing anything to bump off.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Yoda on July 29, 2005, 02:12:37 AM: Fucking evil!
i can't dload from TGA anymore, it says this:

Forbidden
You don't have permission to access /NoNRGZone[SVC3].zip on this server.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apache/2.0.50 (Fedora) Server at www.tgahq.com Port 80

does anyone know why this happens?
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Tackleberry on July 29, 2005, 02:28:14 AM: @Yoda: Same problem for me.

IÃ‚Â´ve seen all vids but BuzzsawÃ‚Â´s. Maybe I have to wait with voting then...
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: kr3mlin on July 29, 2005, 02:52:54 AM: Quote
i can't dload from TGA anymore, it says this:

Forbidden
You don't have permission to access /NoNRGZone[SVC3].zip on this server.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apache/2.0.50 (Fedora) Server at www.tgahq.com Port 80

Just got that too for another d/l

Thanks for the votes so far from everyone who voted me :P
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: DeathCobra on July 29, 2005, 04:20:15 AM: Phew,thought I had reached my d/l limit.Glad its not just me.Maybe TGA have broken thier bandwidth again.
EDIT:Well thats just great.Filefront is running at 37 kb/s.And Ive got a nice 2mb connection.lol
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: impulse on July 29, 2005, 05:04:41 AM: Quote
Fucking evil!
i can't dload from TGA anymore, it says this:

Forbidden
You don't have permission to access /NoNRGZone[SVC3].zip on this server.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Apache/2.0.50 (Fedora) Server at www.tgahq.com Port 80

does anyone know why this happens?
Meh 2 : ((
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 29, 2005, 07:08:05 AM: Looks like Buzzsaw is winning. Too bad some peple doesnt say what vid they voted for and why.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Yoda on July 29, 2005, 07:18:47 AM: I didn't vote on anyone yet, because i can't dload the vids anymore, and i still had to see buzzsaws vid and fredens vid
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 29, 2005, 07:41:55 AM: In the next poll there will be more security for keeping popularity votes and more out. It's updated with the rules of voting in the SVC thread frontpage.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: impulse on July 29, 2005, 08:45:05 AM: Quote
I didn't vote on anyone yet, because i can't dload the vids anymore, and i still had to see buzzsaws vid and fredens vid
Yeah i downloaded the vids,

Dannye_36 vid
I liked a couple of stunts
I loved the intro and other editing.
Stunts where pretty good but maybe a bit easy

-

Mr magic vid
I liked the song : ))
Stunt where pretty oke,
didnt like u showed 1 grind like 4 more times to make ur vid longer

-

Impulse vid
U SUCK ! :P whahah

-

Marklund vid
I liked the editing and the vid flowed very well
Some neto stunts :) great song whehe.
i didnt show like 1 stunts twice

-

Kr3mlin vid
Some great stunts cool cycle stunts like the wall2backwardwheelie
Good music and good flowing vid.

-

Yoda vid
Didnt really liked the music
editing was pretty oke
Some good stunts :)

-

Freden vid
Cool intro ;)
good editing,
1 Special stunts the air plane grind i liked :)
Music was oke

-

Buzzsaw
Nice theme no nrg zone :)
cool music and yeah editing wasnt much as u said but it flowed well
I liked the freeway2treebump and the stoppie on the tram or what is it called

-------

I voted for marklund
WHY !!!
Well his vid flowed very nice great intro and all his stunts where cool
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Yoda on July 29, 2005, 09:04:50 AM: I voted for Freden because of the very original planegrind and the stunts looked pretty clean, GJ dude
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: cyrix on July 29, 2005, 10:16:03 AM: My vote goes towards marklund. I feel his stunts had great variety, amplitude, and cleanliness. To me his video portrayed just how "extreme" (god I hate that word) SA stunting could really be. And this vote is based solely on his stunts, if I counted editing he would win hands down in that as well.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: marklund on July 29, 2005, 10:25:42 AM: Quote
My vote goes towards marklund. I feel his stunts had great variety, amplitude, and cleanliness. To me his video portrayed just how "extreme" (god I hate that word) SA stunting could really be. And this vote is based solely on his stunts, if I counted editing he would win hands down in that as well.
Thanks alot dude! :wub:
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Freden on July 29, 2005, 11:21:09 AM: thanks for the votes :)
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Kert on July 29, 2005, 12:26:30 PM: my vote went to freden coz of the drop2rail and the plane grind was cool too. but good job all.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: Scorpio on July 31, 2005, 08:56:59 PM: ive yet to see buzzsaws and fredens. is tga screwy for anyone else? it says i dont have permission to access the server but im logged in.
Title: SVC 3 Poll (REAL ONE!)
Post by: kr3mlin on August 01, 2005, 12:57:00 AM: tga can sometimes get a bit screwy. And we could be so close to finishing this poll