GTAStunting
General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: Fugitive on November 23, 2006, 11:54:13 AM
-
The Final - Voting poll 2
Tackleberry vs. firefly
Project: Manip
Stock: http://img56.imageshack.us/img56/7829/nycn...tystatuemm5.jpg (http://img56.imageshack.us/img56/7829/nycnewyorklibertystatuemm5.jpg) (check it before voting please)
Rules: http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=15366 (http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=15366)- Anyone can vote.
- You must have a valid reason. If you will only say "My vote goes to XYZ", your vote won't be counted.
- Competitors cannot vote in their own battles.
- You must have more then 30 posts to be able to vote.
- You have 24 hours to vote.
Tackleberry's:
[img]http://img212.imageshack.us/img212/3893/gfxt2finalmanipcopyry8.jpg\" border=\"0\" alt=\"IPB Image\" /]
firefly's:
[img]http://i84.photobucket.com/albums/k18/firefly2347/nyc.png\" border=\"0\" alt=\"IPB Image\" /]
Good luck!
-
My vote goes to Tackleberry .
Because of the nice black&white style and he was more creativ .
GJ to both of you.
-
firefly got my vote.
The old-fashion feel just drives me crazy, but in a good way. It really looks like it's from a Godfather movie. Tackleberry's just looks odd; it's unsharpened, hazy and some random blokes running around there but I really can't blame him because he didn't choose the stock.
-
I vote Tackleberry on this one, its more creative plus looks like firefly didnt do much....
-
Definatly firefly. Tackleberries was a very creative idea, but it looks too out of place to look good. Firefly's looks really good, hand chopped off and the hole in the entrance Nice work.
-
well to be honest FF really only chopped of the hand and appiled some adjsutments
tac on the other hand made a extrmely creative design,
Tac has my vote for showing all you nubs that manips are jsutr fucking color adjstments
-
My vote goes to Tackleberry, bacause it's creative.
Firelfy's pic is also pretty funny but a bit simple.
-
Tackleberry > firefly
4 > 3
-
my vote goes to firefly beocuse the colors
-
I'll vote Tackleberry 'cause I think FF's is a bit too simple for a GFXT final... Then I can't be sure of it since I'm not very good at photoshoping but I like better TB's render.
-
My vote goes to firefly, because he actually used the stock that was given. Tack just chose his own stock, while firefly actually "played by the rules".
-
Tackleberry = firefly
5 = 5
-
My vote goes to firefly, because he actually used the stock that was given. Tack just chose his own stock, while firefly actually "played by the rules".
The only rule was to make a manip and use the stock given. There was no rules about that other stocks could be used too. Therefore I think I followed the rules. If it was against the rules, I believe Fugitive wouldn't have posted this thread.
Thanks for the votes everyone.
-
^ He's right.
-
I believe X didn't actually SEE the statue hidden in the crowd, I didnt at first either
-
I believe X didn't actually SEE the statue hidden in the crowd, I didnt at first either
I didnt see it til u said that
firefly's is pretty boring and now that i see tac. used the stock too Ill give him my vote, sorry for being sleepy, it sure looks cool statue is blended VERY good soo
-
Firefly Because it just seems so old fashioned, easy to make but nice idea.
-
6-6
Whoever gets the next vote gets 1 point.
If firefly wins this poll, he wins the GFXT.
-
I don't know anything about graphics or stuff like that, but I do know which graphics look good and which ones don't (in my opinion).
All I know is 2 people were given a stock and had to make a creative manipulation of that. In my opinion, Tackleberry did that better than firefly. Tac integrated the stock into a whole new context, which impressed me. Then again, I don't know anything about graphics stuff, and how hard it is to make something. So all I know is Tac's impressed me more, that's why he get's my vote.
-
Tackleberry wins 1 point.
Closed.