GTAStunting
General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: Fugitive on October 14, 2006, 10:33:09 PM
-
Round 2 - Battle 4 - Voting poll
Aries vs. Spoof
Project: Signature
Theme: Intelligence (by ExPlosion)
Rules: http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=15366 (http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=15366)- Anyone can vote.
- You must have a valid reason. If you will only say "My vote goes to XYZ", your vote won't be counted.
- Competitors cannot vote in their own battles.
- You must have more then 30 posts to be able to vote.
- You have 24 hours to vote.
Aries's:
[img]http://i41.photobucket.com/albums/e262/AriesKingdom/Entry1.jpg\" border=\"0\" alt=\"IPB Image\" /]
Spoof's:
[img]http://i77.photobucket.com/albums/j56/SmashDood/Signatures/AriesvsSpoof.png\" border=\"0\" alt=\"IPB Image\" /]
Good luck!
-
my vote: aries
aries' is just so different and stands out, and he chose a nice render
spoof's is the same style every time, don't get me wrong it looks good, it's just getting a tad boring now
-
Spoof gets my vote, his just looks so much more appealing to me.
-
Aries GMV.
Spoof: Nothing against Spoof he's a really hard worker and he does the job right(great pun ) but I felt it was empty with color and the background was kind of empty for an intelligence theme. For an intelligence theme, you should use more of technical render and outlook on the signature via colors. The smudging is great though, also I love the cinematic borders.
Aries: I loved the color and I loved the text, the render through me in awe since you worked your name on the render just like the other text on there. Although I felt your render should have been exposed a wee-bit more by sharpening or depth rather. And last but not least, like I said to Spoof, your overall needs to be more technical.
Tech brushes may have done the job. But I guess people have sort of drifted away from that these days. Both poor and great job on both sides.
-
This must've been the hardest theme so far and I think the competitors did a good job, considering that. Aries found a nice render, which take most of the space, though he made it work quite good. Spoof's is nice too, but I think it's too plain. It's not as interesting as the one by Aries.
My vote goes to Aries.
It's more original, got better coloring and is more interesting to watch.
-
X2 with Eric , spoof gets my vote
better colors , and stylischer
-
aries cause of the render and the simplicity of the signature.. it also has more colours and it also has a perfect cut
-
Aries: 4
Spoof: 2
If someone give's me two more votes, it's a tie
-
Spoof gets my vote
You have been using that style for quite some time now but I like it.
Aries coloring is really nice though.
Good job guys and see ya in round 3
-
Aries sig has a great render, amazing colors and i fucking love the text. i can't think of something to whine about O.o
Spoof's sig i s bit boring to me,.. it could use some colour and the brushing is kinda plain.
Aries get's my vote
-
aries gets my vote, although spoofs is really nice, out of the two aries is a better sig imo. the text on aries' sig is very nice, the render speaks for itself. the color is nice aswell. spoofs is a nice looking sig but its a bit boring in comparison with matts, n the text on spoofs isnt the best imo.
-
My vote goes to Aries, the color is brilliant, the placement is perfect, the text only makes the sig better. Why wouldn't anyone vote for Aries.
-
my vote is to spoof, his is just more cool looking to me.
-
X2 with Eric , spoof gets my vote
better colors , and stylischer
there wern't even colors in his sig...
-
Well it look's like Aries won, good job mate
-
Well it look's like Aries won, good job mate
Dude, it's 12 hours left...calm down
-
It's 7 to 4, incase somekind of Christmas miracle happens he wins
-
I vote for Spoof.
Reasons: I really like that style of signature, and I think that the render fits perfectly and is very well blended.
-
And the score she is a turnin' Thank you VenomX
Aries: 7
Spoof: 5
-
My vote goes to Aries It was very close tho Spoof
I liked the text, it fit nicely with the sig and was placed perfectly. Subtle colouring, nicely blended for extra 'wow' factor
-
My vote goes to Spoof
Spoof's has a better feel to it, I like the way the blue sticks out. Aries sig is good but it looks out of focus on some parts. I do like how the "Aries' text looks like it's actually on the metal.
-
Aries: 8
Spoof: 6
I could only use one more vote so then I'll at least loose by one vote not by two
-
Aries FFS
Spoof got pwned hard
-
I think this time i Vote For SpooF , I liked the the sig the feel of it
-
Aries FFS
Spoof got pwned hard
Aries: 8
Spoof: 7
Tsunami, I wouldn't say that losing with one vote is pwning because you didn't specify a reason why you voted for Aries
-
Time's up.
Aries: 8 votes
Spoof: 4 votes
I only counted the valid votes.
Aries wins. Good job.
Closed.