GTAStunting

General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: Xtramus on January 21, 2006, 12:28:48 AM

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: Xtramus on January 21, 2006, 12:28:48 AM

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v245/Torque-/Photoshop%20Stuff/FallingAway.jpg)
Torque's entry

(http://img459.imageshack.us/img459/7545/water11gm.jpg)
Qouad's entry

Voting Rules Here (http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=10047)

The theme was water, anything that's got to do with water.

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: Xtramus on January 21, 2006, 12:32:26 AM

Torque:
Great manip, I love the work on the scanlines, and the foggish damp as well(whether that'd be your work or not). Text also looks good, I like everything about it.

Qouad:
Pixel stretch.. So old and oh so simple. The render looks good, but then again it's not that good. The brushing looks a bit off as well, along with the bubbles above the text..

My vote: Torque.

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: WEREWOLF on January 21, 2006, 12:33:10 AM

Torque: awesome sig, pretty simple, but still looks very good.

Qouad's: nice sig, it isn't really my style, but everything was good.

My vote: Torque, i just liked his sig more.

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: Firefly on January 21, 2006, 01:02:36 AM

Torque: Nice, I like the scene there. Nice job with the manip too, works nicely.

Qouad: I don't like the render, it seems blurry and it's too small. I have never liked the look of pixel stretch either.

My vote: Torque

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: InsaNe on January 21, 2006, 01:05:17 AM

Torque: Very nice, it looks awesome and it goes with theme. Only minus is from text because it looks weird.

Qouad: Pretty nice but it really misses the theme because i can't see any water there, only some bubbles. I liked torque's style more

My vote: Torque

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: Qouad on January 21, 2006, 01:33:20 AM

Quote

Qouad: Pretty nice but it really misses the theme because i can't see any water there, only some bubbles.

well...I couldnt come up with something better than this but i mean...bathball and a girl dressed in a bading suit. (have some fantasy :P)

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: Tackleberry on January 21, 2006, 04:37:11 AM

Torque: Bad colors and way to plain. Not a good manip IMO.

Qouad: A simple pixelstrech with an ugly render. Bad text and I think you should stop adding that outerglow on text in all of your sigs.

My vote: Torque. Not very good, but a bit better than Quad's.

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: yellow please on January 21, 2006, 05:51:11 AM

Torque : very nice i like the way you used the lines a sort of paths for the over exposure

Qouad: not best you could have done its really the sort of thing i would expect from a person of less experience , placing a render  and pixel streching is showing very little of your talent , think out side the box ?

good job both of you but my vote goes to Torque

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: .priest on January 21, 2006, 07:17:58 AM

I love the concept in Torque's. Good work, but the text is weak. I like the boxes alot too.

Qouad's is nice, but not related to water enough IMO. I like the bubbles around the text.

My vote: T.

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: Torque on January 21, 2006, 07:27:27 AM

Kick ass. :P

Thanks for the votes guys.

BTW X, the fogish damp is just some scrweing around with the smudge tool. ;)

Title: POLL: Torque vs. Qouad
Post by: Turtle Dick on January 21, 2006, 03:40:07 PM

Torque's one looks great except for the T.
I don't really like Qouad's one, it looks too common.

My vote: Torque