GTAStunting
General => Expression Section => General Discussion => Graphic Tournament => Topic started by: Xtramus on January 15, 2006, 01:29:54 AM
-
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v456/Lethalboy44/bordersmaller.jpg)
Aries' entry
(http://img488.imageshack.us/img488/248/natur15ct.jpg)
Qouad's entry
Voting Rules Here (http://www.gtastunting.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=10047&view=findpost&p=171122)
Aries
Looks nice. Text and "background" fitted, both very green :P. Nice work, but a bit overdone.
Qouad
Another great one, it was soothing - the calmness was very nice, something I don't see every day in the GFX section. The text was great, simple, but the transparancy made it work. The stuff on the outsides is a a bit overdone though.
My vote: Hard choice, but I vote Aries. It was hard though, Qouad has a very nice entry as well, but I didn't really like the stuff on his edges.
-
Aries - very nice background, good text and it fits the background very good, i liked the color too, good job
Qouad - nice ornament, but i didn't liked the text and the squares a lot, also the sig looks too light so the ornament tooks the view from backgroung and this is more bad than good for me.
My vote: Aries, he made an awesome sig, Qouad's one was nice too but Aries just made so good one that it was hard to beat him.
-
I like aries's style but quoaodaddd's is more professional
hmm, Aries has my vote
-
Aries - Cool manip. The text isn't perfect, but the rest is good.
Qouad - Nice idea, but you didn't manage to make it very good. Much on the sig doesn't fit and the text isn't very nice.
My vote: Aries.
-
Aries entry: Has a nice touch with the darker part, very nice indeed. It's a very nice sig indeed, wouldn't mind having it myself :P
Qouads Entry: Like Xtramus said, a sence of calmness, it's a beautiful sig, only negative would be the ornaments, maby, but without them it would look pretty boring.
Both very nice entrys, my vote goes to Qouad!
-
Aries: Very nice, but I don't like the green, and it's too much contrast imo.
Qouad: Very nice, I like the border, but the text wasn't very good.
My vote: Qouad
-
Aries: Nature photomanip! :D You know I like those. A bit too much contrast and green.
Qouad: I love the concept, but the text and grid kinda kill it. It was a good idea to make the border thingies, but I think you over did it.
My vote: Aries.
-
Vote: Quoad.
It is more nature color in it.
-
Voted for Aries. Its very natural and clean
-
To start:
Qouad: Learn to manip, your image just looks like you blurred it then added the custom shapes to it cause you ran out of ideas.
Aries: Don't overdue one color, when you manip you can bring out a color that is hiding in the sig to make an effect. But yours is already pretty fucking green so next time just go with a lighter tone to your contrast and color.
My vote: Aries, because his is actually a photomanip. Very easy to look at, may have over done color and contrast but still is a very well put together piece.
Cheers
-
I have voted for Aries, because of these things:
Aries has a very nice picture, nice manip, but the border could have been better imo, but all fits together well.
Qouad's one looks more lik a picutre in a photo frame to me, sorry. It just doesn't look like its one piece.
-
Aries: Nice, but way too green. The text is ok, but the color is weird here too. Fits with the rest of the sig. It's great, but maybe overdone.
Qouad: Nice and calm, but not much done here. The shapes are weird, but I like the subtle grid pattern. The text is ok, but the placement should be worked on.
My vote: Aries. The color is really fucked, but otherwise a good sig.
-
Aries, Qouad could've won if he had the right text and manip.