ROUND 1: Valu vs Phamus [Phamus Won]

[XTO --]

Competitors: Valu vs Phamus

Objective: Create the most beautiful video using only Blurs and Color Corrections
Stunt: http://www.4shared.com/rar/1gvgyOD1/Valu_vs_Phamus.html
(Stunt by ZeRo)


Deadline: 3 days from now


Note: Objectives regarding looks and color corrections, will be rated according to this:

• Best look: Look>Color Correction>Editing
• Best Color Correction: Color Correction>Look>Editing

[value]

Best look: Look>Color Correction>Editing
Best Color Correction: Color Correction>Look>Editing

? ? ?

[XTO --]

Note: Objectives regarding looks and color corrections, will be rated according to this:

[value]

I am not 5 dude, I can read.
explain me the difference between "Look" and Color Correction

[Phamus]

Look, as in the setting of GTA:SA.
Surroundings basically.

[XTO --]

^Look: How beautiful your game is

Color Correction, fitting, enhancing color

[value]

ready soon

[value]

GTAS.ET 2012 - [valu] vs Phamus

gl

[Phamus]

Nice one, bro! Really good You totally astonished me with that CC and quality.
But here:

GTASET - Round 1 - [Phamus] vs Valu


 !

[Ltab-]

Tight match, both awesome editings..

Valu: Stunning blur effects you've used, it looked pretty cool. I also really liked the CC, that white diffusion feeling always it's great. Some cam angles looked weird sometimes and it's pretty weird to see that on you I suppose. Maybe I'm more like "added" to VC movement, but good work.

Phamus: The camera showing the whole city looked awesome combined with the beggining of the song (Don't think that I didn't saw the sync fail at 0:29 ) other than the CC looked more fitting to the challenge itself, and camera movement too. Except for the first few angles that pancrop looked weird. Overall I think your entry sticks to the challenge.


Vote goes to ..

e/ didn't noticed that valu, good question. Gonna give my vote after XTO decides..

[XTO --]

Ok, this match has to do with Color Corrections and overall looks. His pan/crops will be left aside since it does not take part into the ratings.

To judges: You should rate based on how good each clip looks like, overall editing as effecs, pan/crops and anything else is just a "tie" criteria

[Ltab-]

This was also best good looking sa related too, but I'll be fast and just stick to rate CC as challenge says. I'll just wait and see for who I will vote, I'm doing this since I have a medium knowledge about editing in SA so..

[GDL]

I'm going to vote for valu, because Phamus' one had too much pink/purple which made it look too overdone and unrealistic.

My vote goes to valu.

Phamus, sorry for your mom, you're probably devastated

[Phamus]

Yeah, i just returned from editing..

And I guess all those blurs I've done were meanless, I tried sticking to the objective of good color corrections and blur, but oh wekk 

[Christian]

I loved what Phamus did, that intro gave such a great feeling and so many HARD chills, but then it was a bit of a let down. Didnt felt like the intro did, also the quality wasn't that good and the CC is "oneminded" if you know what I mean.

Valu's work was slightly better - short and effective intro, great looks on the game and nice song which got me somehow happy...ish. My vote goes to Valu althought I was this close to vote for Phamus.