POLL - MA vs. Dil-Bert

[Xtramus]

MA's entry


Dil-Bert's entry

Voting Rules Here

I like the "render" Dil-Bert used. It was more "stunting" than MA's. However, MA's text was way better IMHO than Dil-Bert's. Also, the "render" MA used seem much harder to make: more edges and stuff.

MY vote: MA.

[WEREWOLF]

MA - nice font, very nice bg color, the render is quite strange, it looks like eh..oh, it's a gun but it's not really stunt related, and i didn't like that the text is too close to the render

Dil-Bert - i like your render more and it's stunt related, but the font is not as good as MA's one and i don't like the bg color

My vote: MA, it was hard to decide, both sigs have good and bad aspects but the text and the bg color was the main point for me to make my vote so that's why i liked MA's one a little bit more

[Liviu]

I vote MA,his text is much better and the color doesnt hurt my eyes like Dil-Berts does.The turismo looks cool but the weaker text i dont like

[Qouad]

hmm...hard one.

They are both well made. i think MAs is a little bit nicer and so, BUT i find Dil-berts one more stunt related. thats why...
My vote goes to: Dil-Bert

[Tackleberry]

MA - Nice and clean, good job.

Dil-Bert - Don't like the text and how everything is placed.

My vote: MA.

[Fugitive]

MA: Nice background color and nice font.
Bil-Bert: Nice but I don't like the green and the font.

My vote: MA

[.priest]

MA: Background and font are awesome. Unfortunately, the render is not about stunting.

D-B: Background is too flashy and text is bleh. But your render is stunting related.

My vote: D-B for following the rulez.

[Aries]

Dilbert: Nice, but text didnt' look right, and you just threw the render on.

MA: Text is nicer, and render was places with some kind of thought

The challenge was kinda pants, it could be done in paint, but my vote goes to:
             MA

[Tackleberry]

It looks like MA will win this (which I also think is right), but it's up to Xtramus to tell if he followed the rules or not.

[InsaNe]

MA's: Looks soft, looks like an real iPod pic.

Dilbert's: Looks nice too but text is croppy and doesn't have as much iPod feel as MA's

[Tackleberry]

MA's: Looks soft, looks like an real iPod pic.

Dilbert's: Looks nice too but text is croppy and doesn't have as much iPod feel as MA's

Does that mean you vote for MA's? It looks like that, but it's as obvious as it should be.

[InsaNe]

MA's: Looks soft, looks like an real iPod pic.

Dilbert's: Looks nice too but text is croppy and doesn't have as much iPod feel as MA's

Does that mean you vote for MA's? It looks like that, but it's as obvious as it should be.

Yea that means i vote for MA, forgot to put that    

[MisguidedAngel]

Just for the sake of it...the little car in the button...its a cabbie. Cab stunting people (yes I know its hard to tell cause of the size so I appologize for that)

thanks for le votes

[Firefly]

MA: I like the color and placement of things. The font isn't the same as in the iPod commercials, but no big deal.

Dil-bert: The stroke on the text isn't cool, but the font is good. The color of it is weird. Placement of stuff makes it look odd.

My vote: MA

[Torque]

Dil-bert, just wanna see MA lose.

Nah jk, but Dil's did have more of a stunt feel to it, so I voted for him.